SearchDonation.com

HC quashes Delhi govt mid-day meal scheme condition for NGOs

News posted on: 2018-06-07 03:39:16 , By Admin
 

New Delhi, Jun 6 (PTI) The Delhi High Court today quashed the Delhi government's eligibility condition related to average annual turnover for NGOs seeking tender of the mid-day cooked meal scheme, terming it as "arbitrary" and "unreasonable".

The court directed the Delhi government to appropriately rework the eligibility condition (of possessing an average annual turnover of Rs 3 crore for the preceding 3 years) and other minimum requirements to enable wider participation of NGOs.

"This court is of the opinion that the impugned eligibility condition is arbitrary and unreasonable, and is accordingly quashed," a bench of justices S Ravindra Bhat and A K Chawla said.

The court's order came on a petition by four NGOs challenging the tender condition formulated by the Delhi government while inviting bids for the mid-day cooked meals scheme.

The NGOs had alleged that the eligibility condition of a minimum threshold of Rs 3 crore average financial turnover,

during the previous three years, was arbitrary.

The petitioners submitted that they were voluntary NGOs formed between 1995 and 2006 and were ISO certified agencies and have been providing services to the Delhi government in the past by supplying mid-day meals to children studying in its schools.

They had said the mandate of the guidelines was to promote charitable organisations only, which were willing to work on a no-profit basis. The scheme of supplying mid-day-meal was a benevolent scheme aimed at providing nutritional hot cooked meal to poor children studying in government and aided schools or institutions.

They had said that by incorporating the pre-qualification criteria, the essence of the scheme to associate with voluntary organisations has been violated and commercialisation was being promoted and it was highly improbable to believe that an NGO having experience of five years could have a turnover of Rs 3 crore average annually.

The Delhi government's counsel had submitted that the re-modeling of the clusters meant that under the request for proposal issued by the Directorate of Education, each successful bidder had to supply to a larger group or cluster- with a minimum student size of 35000.

Unless the contractor NGO had sufficient financial capability to wait for release of funds, which took about 4 months, it would fold up and in effect go bankrupt, it said, adding that this meant that a higher ability to withstand had to necessarily be indicated.

The court, however, said that the emphasis by the Delhi government that the NGO concerned should be able to sustain four months itself without payment was "baseless and unreasonable" and "wholly irrational and arbitrary".

"A deeper analysis would show that what the government of NCT of Delhi is saying that its existing administrative capability is so inefficient that the bills of every NGO would take at least four months for processing which is the reason why the eligibility condition needs to be factored in, is also an extraneous and an entirely unreasonable fact. In fact, it amounts to placing a premium on its own inefficiency in the guise of pragmatism," the court said.

It also noted that change in the criteria was influenced by the size of the NGOs who were providing mid day meals to the three municipal corporations -- East, South and North.

The court said that in its opinion, the blind and uncritical adoption of the municipal corporation-based model of eligibility criteria, which was based upon 18 NGOs catering to varying student populations of those schools within their jurisdiction, was "entirely arbitrary and unreasonable". 

Read more: Click Here

You may like similar news

Tata Trust's FISE develops low-cost portable MRI scanner to take health services to rural India

  2018-06-07 21:54:58

BENGALURU: Tata Trusts’ Foundation for Innovation and Social Entrepreneurship (FISE) has developed a high-tech portable Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanner, designed to make MRI affordable and accessible for everyone. The product was devel...

Read in detail

Maternal mortality drops to 130, Kerala top, big improvement in backward states

  2018-06-07 05:54:13

NEW DELHI: India has registered significant improvement in an area where it has lagged — maternal deaths have reduced from 167 in 2011-13 to 130 (per 100,000 live births) in 2014-16 with Kerala leading the table, according to new data released ...

Read in detail

RAF barracks turned into home for cancer patients

  2018-06-05 00:20:31

Navi Mumbai: The barracks once housing the paramilitary troops of 102Bn Rapid Action Force (RAF) in Taloja has now become a centre for cancer patients. Around 50 houses have been built in the 10 unused barracks. The rooms are equipped with beds, a c...

Read in detail

Indian Mental Health NGO is helping parents become their child's therapist

  2018-06-03 23:47:24

Dr. Ajay Khera, Deputy Commissioner from the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare along with global mental health expert and one of Time 100's most influential people, Prof. Vikram Patel launched a novel parent mediated program for autism for India'...

Read in detail

President calls for greater awareness on organ donation

  2018-05-30 05:36:09

Surat, May 29 President Ram Nath Kovind today urged medical and educational institutions to create awareness about organ donation to help a larger number of people in need of such organs and their families get get a fresh lease of life. Speaking her...

Read in detail

View More...

Find News By

News By State News By Category News By City News By Country
 

Our Services

Latest Top Jobs

Online Community Manager

Quest Alliance
  2018-07-10         Karnataka
View & Apply

Park Manager

Centre for Environment Education (CEE)
  2018-06-30         Gujarat
View & Apply

Accountant

Asheray Welfare And Charitable Society
  2018-07-10         Delhi
View & Apply

Manager - Events

Cansupport
  2018-07-10         Delhi
View & Apply

Community Mobilizer

Creation Welfare Society
  2018-07-06         Bihar
View & Apply
Jobs By State
Jobs By Industry
Jobs By City
Jobs By Country

New Funds For NGO

The Strategic Legal Fund for Vulnerable Young Migrants

  2018-07-06

About the Strategic Legal Fund The Strategic Legal Fund for Vulnerabl...

Read in detail
Funds By Our Work
Funds By State
Funds By City
Funds By Country

Join Us Free

NGO   Company   Candidate   Guest
   
7909

I agree to all the Terms of Use stated herein.

All rights reserved © 2018 Sahaniya Technologies Pvt. Ltd.